📌
Case Study No. 2: The Oracle of Domestic Guesswork — or How Not to Raise Children with Wi-Fi and Ego Alone
Let us begin with a simple observation: if the human heart were a piano, there are those who would attempt to play it using a banana. It is not that the banana lacks charm. It may be colourful, vaguely nutritious, and pleasing to wave about while shouting. But the sound it produces when thumped upon ivory is neither music nor revelation.
Such is the method of the self-proclaimed mentor of family life, that illustrious Wi-Fi prophetess who, armed with nothing but a webcam, a misplaced confidence, and what could plausibly be the colourful echoes of several less-than-triumphant adventures in matrimony, has declared herself an authority on matters of love, partnership, and child-rearing. A curious thing, considering that her children seem, at least from the outside, to be participants in a private experiment of ‘education’ which might, to the casual observer, resemble prolonged isolation.
It is here that satire collides headlong with tragedy. For while she parades her domestic wisdom as if it were silk spun from the loom of Athena, the cloth is in fact cobbled from ideological lint and parental negligence.
The Theatre of Expertise (Without the Expertise)
Every family is a delicate cosmos, a constellation of affections, tensions, histories, and hopes. To advise on such matters requires not merely personal experience, but studied knowledge: psychology, pedagogy, ethics, communication, cultural context. To substitute this with “what worked for me on a Tuesday” is not mentorship. It is domestic gambling.
Picture a surgeon who assures you that, though she has no training, she once stitched a button successfully and therefore feels entirely competent to remove your spleen. You would, quite rightly, run screaming into the night. And yet, when it comes to the delicate tissue of relationships and the fragile architecture of a child’s development, people will sometimes entrust themselves to precisely this level of banana-wielding amateur.
The danger, dear reader, is not comic but corrosive. Families who arrive vulnerable, already bruised by conflict or weighed by uncertainty, are offered certainty in the form of slogans: “The woman must teach the man how to be a man.” “Tradition will save us.” “If you don’t know how to create a home, you are nothing but an empty shell.”
These are not teachings. They are blunt instruments—tools of shame and conformity dressed up as insight. And when wielded by someone whose only credential is her own biography of collapses and parental experiments, they are not only absurd; they are dangerous.
The Comedy of Authority
It is tempting, of course, to laugh. One can hardly resist. To witness a woman who seems to extol the importance of ‘family tradition’ while apparently conducting her own eccentric version of education at home is a paradox almost too perfect to be accidental and a comedy of the purest kind.
S/he, this so-called ‘awakened enlightened soul,’ seems to have little else to offer the world but her own contradictions.
To hear her declare that women must guide men into manhood — and that she alone holds the key to this mysterious art — while her own record most likely, though one can never truly know, and even as the so-called ‘enlightened soul’ cheerfully admits as part of the persuasive machinery of her marketing, seems peppered with relationships that ended less than gloriously, is a contradiction so glaring it hardly needs pointing out. The lesson she claims to teach appears, in her own life, to have been repeatedly unlearned — an irony so rich it could be sliced and served on toast.
And to see her proclaim herself a guide of guides, selling packages of mentorship to other would-be impostors, is pure Dumasian farce—the Cardinal Richelieu of mediocrity, orchestrating an empire of hollow disciples.
After all, one can never truly know, even when one thinks one does; and precisely for this reason, guidance in matters of family and personal development should be grounded in formal accreditation and demonstrated competence, not merely personal experience. What might have worked once — or several times — for someone is by no means a guarantee that it will ever work for anyone else.
The Therapeutic Truth
Let us pause for the sober truth: children are not instruments of ideology. They are not props for branding. They are not pawns to be withdrawn from education on a whim, or leverage to sell “coaching programmes” to anxious mothers.
Every child requires not perfection, but protection: a safe environment, access to knowledge, the chance to encounter difference, the freedom to stumble and grow. Families, likewise, require not slogans, but support grounded in compassion, evidence, and care. When non-experts charge money to play therapist, they do not offer healing; they offer confusion, dependency, and sometimes irreversible harm.
It is the gravest mistake to imagine that because we have lived through something, we therefore know how to guide others through it. The wound does not make the surgeon. If anything, it is precisely the one who has stumbled most chaotically who must tread most carefully when others lean on them.
A Lesson for Reader and Pupil Alike
The lesson, then, is twofold:
For the would-be mentor — To parade your failures as qualifications is not bravery but exploitation. To preach family values while depriving your children of education is not tradition but neglect. To claim wisdom on the basis of Wi-Fi and charisma is to serve poisoned fruit dressed as ambrosia.
For the reader — To follow such figures is to surrender one’s agency. True mentorship is never sold in instalments, never dressed in shame, never extracted from the vulnerable. It is given carefully, backed by knowledge, tested by scrutiny, and offered without manipulation.
Epilogue: The Banana at the Piano
Let us return, finally, to our piano and its banana. The banana may insist that the sounds it produces are profound. It may even sell tickets to its concert, convincing many that the noise is “revolutionary.” But the discerning listener will know: this is not music. It is racket.
So too with our self-proclaimed mentor. Their pronouncements, however confidently delivered, are not wisdom but mere noise. To laugh at them is salutary; to follow them, perilous. How lamentable it is that the truly competent and ethical teachers are the ones who suffer at the hands of such "enlightened, awakened souls" — a vitally important matter, but another topic to which we might return one day.
And so, dear reader, when next you encounter the clatter of such authority—half-baked slogans, moralising tirades, or the promise of “awakening” sold in twelve easy payments—remember the banana at the piano. Smile, perhaps. Applaud, if you must. But do not, under any circumstance, mistake it for symphony.
For wisdom is not performed; it is practiced. Not sold; but shared. Not imposed; but cultivated.
And if ever you forget this truth, look no further than your own children—their laughter, their questions, their inconvenient honesty. There lies the truest mentor of all.
* All quotations are taken from publicly available online sources and are used here strictly for the purposes of commentary, critique, and analysis, in accordance with the right to quotation.